A significant competition case in Botswana could have implications well beyond its borders, particularly for South Africa’s motor insurance and vehicle repair industries, where similar concerns have been debated for years.
The Botswana Competition and Consumer Authority has referred a matter to the Competition and Consumer Tribunal in Gaborone involving several insurers and a parts procurement platform in the automotive repair sector. At the heart of the case are allegations that certain business practices may have restricted the independence of repairers and distorted competition.
The respondents include Botswana Insurance Company Limited, Hollard Insurance Company of Botswana, Old Mutual Short-Term Insurance Botswana Limited, and Parts Portal (Pty) Ltd, trading as Autobodys Revolve. According to the Authority, the conduct in question may have breached Botswana’s Competition Act by interfering with normal market conditions.
The concerns raised include alleged pressure on labour rates, limits on repairers’ profit margins on spare parts, and requirements for parts to be sourced through a single procurement portal rather than through open market channels. If proven, these practices could point to an excessive degree of control by insurers over how repairs are carried out and priced.
The Authority is also seeking remedies that extend beyond a finding of wrongdoing. These include steps to reverse decisions that may have harmed repairers who previously complained to the regulator, as well as possible financial penalties if the Tribunal finds that competition law was breached.
The wider significance of the case lies in its potential effect on the structure of the repair market. If independent repairers are unable to negotiate labour rates, choose suppliers freely, or compete on fair commercial terms, this may reduce consumer choice, place smaller businesses under strain, and influence both the cost and quality of vehicle repairs.
Although the case is being heard in Botswana, it is likely to attract attention in South Africa, where concerns around insurer influence, approved repair networks, procurement systems, and pricing pressure have long been part of industry discussion. A ruling against the respondents could prompt closer scrutiny of similar arrangements across Southern Africa.
An interlocutory hearing is scheduled for 28 August 2026. While the outcome remains uncertain, the matter is already emerging as an important test of the limits of insurer control within repair supply chains.
Audi South Africa has introduced the new Q5 range, comprising the third-generation Q5 SUV, second-generation Q5 Sportback, and the performance-focused SQ5 SUV and SQ5 Sportback. The range is built on Audi's Premium Platform Combustion and brings a new generation of petrol and diesel engines to the nameplate.
Geely Auto South Africa (GASA) has introduced Riddara, Geely Auto Group's new energy bakkie brand, to the South African market.
Ford’s next big electric vehicle push is less about a dramatic new badge and more about what happens behind factory doors.
Advertisement
Advertisement
Cars are the ultimate symbol of freedom, independence and individualism. They offer the freedom to ‘go anywhere,’ whenever it suits and with whom one chooses.
Sarah Redshaw
The Toyota Starlet has improved from zero to a four-star rating for adult occupant protection in Global NCAP's latest #SaferCarsForAfrica crash test results. This follows a safety upgrade to make six airbags a standard fit.
South Africa's new vehicle market sustained strong momentum in August 2026, with aggregate sales increasing by 11,4% year-on-year to 57 898 units, says the Automotive Business Councill | naamsa.
South Africa’s new-vehicle market maintained its momentum in August, with aggregate sales of 57 898 units representing an increase of 11.4% compared with the same month last year.
